By Rand Winburn Robert Barnes was educated in one of the finest universities in Mediaeval Europe – the Belgian University of Louvain,[2] before coming to Cambridge University as Prior and Master of the Augustinian Order. He brought a high standard of education to the Order, drawing other students from the outside, Miles Coverdale among them. Paul’s Epistles were studied and taught in-depth. Barnes excelled in polemic debates, preaching against the hypocrite bishops, yet was not converted to the true faith until Master Bilney’s witness. In 1525, the Sunday before Christmas, Barnes preached his new-found Protestant faith, even quoting Luther, at St. Edward’s Church, Cambridge. Soon after he was accused of heresy by his prestigious adversaries. Dr. Barnes became the spearhead who attracted gatherings of similar-minded students at what was to be called The White Horse, or Germany – a slur against the so-called ‘heretical’ Protestant Germans. Refusing to recant, Barnes wrote a work for King Henry VIII, defending his position. In 1526, Barnes was arrested, as search was made for Luther’s books, as well as other German Protestant works. Brought to London, he was examined by Cardinal Wolsey and his fellow theologians. “What! Master Doctor,” said the Cardinal, “had you not a sufficient scope in the Scriptures to teach the people, but that my golden shoes, my pole-axes, my pillars, my golden cushions, my crosses did so sore offend you, that you must make us ridiculum caput [3] amongst the people? We were jollily that day laughed to scorn. Verily it was a sermon more fit to be preached on a stage, than in a pulpit; for at the last you said, I wear a pair of red gloves (I should say ‘bloody gloves,’ quoth you), that I should not be cold in the midst of my ceremonies.” And Barnes answered, “I spoke nothing but the truth out of the Scriptures, according to my conscience, and according to the old doctors.” Admitting the Cardinal possessed as much power in England as the Pope, Barnes was asked if he would submit to the Cardinal and his council. Barnes replied, “I thank your grace for your good will; I will stick to the holy Scripture, and to God’s book, according to the simple talent that God hath lent me.” The next day Barnes was brought before a council at Westminster comprising the bishops and abbot. Though they were in the midst of interrogating 5 other men for suspicion of reading Luther and holding Lollard beliefs, they turned their attention to Barnes. Refusing to recant the articles which he had written in his defense,[4] he was relegated to prison until his second appearance later that week. After hours of disputing and threats during his second interrogation, the bishops issued the ultimatum: abjure or burn. At first, Dr. Barnes chose burning, but, after much persuasion from his companions, he agreed to abjure.[5] To perform the abjuration, the Cardinal had a public ceremony prepared in St. Paul’s Church, which was overflowing with spectators. “The cardinal had a scaffold made on the top of the stairs for himself, with six-and-thirty abbots, mitered priors, and bishops, and he, in his whole pomp, mitered (which Barnes spoke against), sat there enthroned, his chaplains and spiritual doctors in gowns of damask and satin, and he himself in purple; even like a bloody Antichrist. And there was a new pulpit erected on the top of the stairs also, for the bishop of Rochester to preach against Luther and Dr. Barnes; and great baskets full of books standing before them, within the rails, which were commanded…to be burned; and these heretics, after the sermon, to go thrice about the fire, and to east in their faggots. Now, while the sermon was a doing, Dr. Barnes and the [Lollard] men were commanded to kneel down, and ask forgiveness of God, of the catholic church and of the cardinal’s grace; ……….and there did he absolve Dr. Barnes with the others, and showed the people that they were received into the church again.” Having been delivered from the Fleet St. jail six months later, he was sent to the Augustinian friars in London, where he underwent further examination, resulting in his being convicted of heresy once more. Cardinal Woolsey ordered Barnes transferred to the Augustinian friars house in Northampton where he was to be burned. Warned by a friend of the fate which awaited him, Robert Barnes faked a suicide note, escaping the country, eventually joining Martin Luther. Under his protection, Barnes wrote a scathing history of the Pontiffs, Acta Romanorum Pontificum, using authoritative Church sources. Finding favor with theologians and nobility, the King of Denmark employed his services as ambassador to Henry VIII. King Henry later gave Barnes a commission to represent him at the marriage of Lady Anne of Cleves. Afterward, an enemy of Barnes, Stephen Gardiner, secretary to Cardinal Wolsey, was responsible for his capture and interrogation at Hampton Court. Still free to preach, Dr. Barnes was again taken prisoner after preaching a sermon in the presence of Gardiner. Once imprisoned in the Tower of London, without trial, Barnes was only to emerge later for his execution. “At his death, Dr. Barnes gave great commendations to the king’s majesty, that he should fear God, and maintain religion, and keep marriage undefiled most honorably; and then declared his faith and his articles.” END TITLE INDEX >> HOME __________________________________________________
[1] Source: Acts and Monuments, John Foxe, 19th century edition, volume 5, Ages Software. [2] In the 16th century it ranked 2nd to the University of Paris in reputation, (Ency. Brit., 1959). [3] In today’s vernacular: “the butt of your jokes.” [4] William Clebsch summarizes them: “Christians were no more bound to serve God on Sunday or holy days than any other day; that in his time nobody dared preach the gospel for fear of being accused of heresy; that contemporaneous executions of ‘heretics’ [Lollards] made true martyrs of the gospel….that scripture gave no precedent for church officials to hold great temporal possessions; that the bishops stood in apostolic succession to Judas as rich men, not to the other apostles or preachers of the gospel…that those pricked by the sermon were Pharisees who inwardly knew the sermon to be true; that bishops and prelates followed the false prophet Balaam by riding upon the common folk as asses; that the prelates set up an idol called Baal Peor; that blessings which should be bestowed freely by servants of Christ were sold for money; that the bishops would sooner part with a benediction than a half-penny; that the sale of indulgences was fraudulent…..that bishops grasped at miters and rings, but gave nothing to the poor; that their miters came from the Jews’ bishops, not from Christ; that the two horns of the miter signified the devil; that they carried staffs, but were not shepherds to the flock…” (England’s Earliest Protestants, [Yale University Press: New Haven, 1964], pp. 46-47.) [5]
Scholar Rainer Pineas relates from Barnes’ own writings that Barnes’
accusers were never made known to him, nor was he told on what basis
he was charged with heresy. In addition, Barnes claims he was tricked
into signing a confession admitting to heresy. (Robert Barnes’
Polemical Use of History: 1964), p. 62. “And so, on the mere basis
of accusation…he was given the choice of either doing open penance
for preaching heresy, or of being burned as a stubborn heretic.” (Ibid.) |